Normative Conflict between Human Rights: Blood Transfusions in Jehovah’s Witness patients in Spain
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54536/ajsl.v4i2.3508Keywords:
Hemotransfusions, Human Rights, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Normative Conflict, Right to Health, Right to Life, Right to Religious FreedomAbstract
The refusal of Jehovah’s Witnesses patients to receive blood transfusions poses a normative conflict between several human rights. On one hand, there is the “Right to Religious Freedom”, which allows these patients to rely on their religious convictions to refuse such medical procedures. On the other hand, there are the “Right to Life” and the “Right to Health”, which obligate healthcare professionals to perform all necessary actions to preserve patients’ lives and improve their health. Additionally, healthcare professionals are bound by the commitments and guidelines of their profession in performing their duties. Within this context, the current study conducts a qualitative analysis of articles, legal instruments, and ethical frameworks. The study employs a legal analysis to explore the normative conflict surrounding blood transfusions for Jehovah’s Witness patients in Spain. It focuses on the interplay between the Right to Religious Freedom, Right to Life, and Right to Health using a qualitative approach. The analysis considers relevant legal instruments, ethical frameworks, and case law to identify critical factors influencing decision-making in medical practice, particularly the patient’s state of consciousness and the urgency of their condition. It concludes that the patient’s state of consciousness and the severity of their condition are the decisive factors. If the patient is conscious and not in a critical condition, their decision to refuse the treatment should take preeminence. Conversely, in cases where a blood transfusion is necessary but not urgent, the matter should be brought before the competent judicial bodies for a decision. However, in situations where the transfusion is both necessary and urgent to save the patient’s life, the decision will be made by the healthcare professionals involved, who must then assume the consequences of their actions.
Downloads
References
Abdulla, M. R. (2018). Culture, religion, and freedom of religion or belief. The Review of Faith & International Affairs, 16(4), 102-115. https://doi.org/10.1080/15570274.2018.1535033
Akah, A. U., Ekpo, T. J., & Okocha, O. C. C. (2023). Rustling and human security in Nigeria-An analysis of ECOWAS response. American Journal of Society and Law, 2(2), 51-57. https://doi.org/10.54536/ajsl.v2i2.2014
Akter, A., & Tamanna, T. (2020). Fundamental rights during corona pandemic-Bangladesh perspective: A study special reference to access to justice and fair trial, legal protection and right to life. In BiLDBANGLADESH. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/346329715_Fundamental_Rights_during_Corona_Pandemic-Bangladesh_Perspective_A_Study_Special_Reference_to_Access_to_Justice_and_Fair_Trial_Legal_Protection_and_Right_to_Life
Anderson, E., Tremper, C., Thomas, S., Wagenaar, A. C., & Burris, S. (2012). Measuring statutory law and regulations for empirical research.
Ashworth, A. (2019). Victims’ rights, defendants’ rights and criminal procedure. In Integrating a victim perspective within criminal justice (pp. 185-204). Routledge.
Avant, L. C., & Swetz, K. M. (2020). Revisiting beneficence: What is a ‘Benefit’, and by what criteria? The American Journal of Bioethics, 20(3), 75-77. https://doi.org/10.1080/15265161.2020.1714796
Bidart Campos, G. J. (1998). Manual de la Constitución reformada.
Blanchet Garneau, A., Browne, A. J., & Varcoe, C. (2019). Understanding competing discourses as a basis for promoting equity in primary health care. BMC Health Services Research, 19, 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-019-3981-9
Bolcato, M., Shander, A., Isbister, J. P., Trentino, K. M., Russo, M., Rodriguez, D., & Aprile, A. (2021). Physician autonomy and patient rights: Lessons from an enforced blood transfusion and the role of patient blood management. Vox Sanguinis, 116(10), 1023-1030. https://doi.org/10.1111/vox.13122
Burkholder, T. W., Hill, K., & Hynes, E. J. C. (2019). Developing emergency care systems: A human rights-based approach. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 97(9), 612. https://doi.org/10.2471/BLT.18.224139
Camosy, C. C. (2021). Losing our dignity: How secularized medicine is undermining fundamental human equality. New City Press.
Canamares, S. (2010). The Spanish Organic Law on religious freedom: Appropriateness and grounds for amendment. IUS Canonicum, 50, 477.
Casey-Maslen, S., & Heyns, C. (2021). The right to life under international law: An interpretative manual. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108881515
Chemerinsky, E. (2023). Constitutional law. Aspen Publishing.
da Silva Rodrigues, Q. P., Lins, S. M. d. S. B., & Peres, E. M. Blood and blood component transfusion for Jehovah’s Witnesses: A scoping review.
Dalli, M. (2020). The content and potential of the right to social assistance in light of Article 13 of the European Social Charter. European Journal of Social Security, 22(1), 3-23. https://doi.org/10.1177/1388262720912272
Daly, E. (2020). Dignity rights: Courts, constitutions, and the worth of the human person. University of Pennsylvania Press.
De Schutter, O. (2018). The Charter of Fundamental Rights as a social rights charter.
Delmas-Marty, M. (2021). The European Convention for the protection of human rights: International protection versus national restrictions (Vol. 19). Brill. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004478441
Domaradzka, A. W. (2023). Children’s rights with disabilities and alternative care between universal and regional (Council of Europe) standards of protection. European Integration Studies, 19(1). https://doi.org/10.5755/j01.eis.19.1.33392
Dziurda, M., Golab, A., & Zembrzuski, T. (2021). European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms: Impact on Polish law development. Access to Justice in Eastern Europe, 23.
Eide, A. (1992). Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In (pp. 377-389): Oslo, Scandinavian University Press.
Ernest, N. A., & Okpokam, D. C. (2019). Bloodless medicine and surgery: A review of practice and consideration of Jehovah’s Witnesses. Asian Journal of Medicine and Health, 16(3), 1-7. https://doi.org/10.9734/ajmah/2019/v16i330143
Figueroa García-Huidobro, R. (2008). Concepto de derecho a la vida. Ius et Praxis, 14(1), 261-300. https://doi.org/10.4067/S0718-00122008000100011
Gilabert, P. (2019). Human dignity and human rights. Oxford University Press, USA.
Giles, J. (2020). A theological justification for freedom of religion and belief as a universal right. In Why religion? Towards a critical philosophy of law, peace and God (pp. 101-136).
Giustina, T. G. a. D. (2021). The principle of human dignity, law and relativism: The challenge of connecting diversity.
Goodale, M. (2022). Reinventing human rights. Stanford University Press.
Gunner, G. (2023). Religious freedom as a human right. In Freedom of religion and religious pluralism (pp. 79-100). Brill Nijhoff. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004530736_006
Harris, D. J., O’Boyle, M., Bates, E., & Buckley, C. (2023). Law of the European Convention on Human Rights. Oxford University Press.
Hemberg, J., & Hemberg, H. (2020). Ethical competence in a profession: Healthcare professionals’ views. Nursing Open, 7(4), 1249-1259. https://doi.org/10.1002/nop2.480
Hernández, M.-A. P. (2020). Ideological freedom and related legal wording. The Age of Human Rights Journal, 14, 109-136. https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v14.5688
Huang, I.-C., Du, P.-L., Lin, L.-S., Liu, T.-Y., Lin, T.-F., & Huang, W.-C. (2021). The effect of perceived value, trust, and commitment on patient loyalty in Taiwan. INQUIRY: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing, 58, 00469580211007217. https://doi.org/10.1177/00469580211007217
Ikawa, D. (2020). The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Optional Protocol. In Research handbook on economic, social and cultural rights as human rights (pp. 14-26). Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781788972130.00010
Juaristi, F. J. R. (2023). Article 1–Dignity and equality. In The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (pp. 12-35). Brill Nijhoff. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004545396_003
Judgement of the Court 28 March ECHR (Court of Justice 2000).
Organic Act 7/1980, of 5 July, On Freedom of Religion, (2017).
Kapelańska-Pręgowska, J. (2019). Medical negligence, systemic deficiency, or denial of emergency healthcare? Reflections on the European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber Judgment in Lopes de Sousa Fernandes v. Portugal of 19 December 2017 and previous case-law. European Journal of Health Law, 26(1), 26-43. https://doi.org/10.1163/15718093-12261036
Kelsen, H. (2022). What is justice?: Justice, law, and politics in the mirror of science. Univ of California Press.
Kwiatkowski, P. (2022). European standard for the protection of patients’ lives. Przegląd Prawniczy Uniwersytetu im. Adama Mickiewicza, 14, 119-137. https://doi.org/10.18566/rfdcp.v46n124.a02
Lagoutte, S. (2003). Surrounding and extending family life: The notion of family life in the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights. Nordic Journal of Human Rights, 21(3), 292-306. https://www.idunn.no/doi/abs/10.18261/ISSN1891-814X-2003-03-03
Lewis, J. (2020). Getting obligations right: Autonomy and shared decision making. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 37(1), 118-140. https://doi.org/10.1111/japp.12383
Loix, S., Henin, P., Descamps, O., & Reusens, I. (2020). Jehovah’s Witnesses and transfusion: Where do we stand in Europe? ISBT Science Series, 15(2), 212-220.
Loveland, I. (2018). Constitutional law, administrative law, and human rights: A critical introduction. Oxford University Press.
Łuków, P. (2018). A difficult legacy: Human dignity as the founding value of human rights. Human Rights Review, 19(3), 313-329.
Makrides, V. N. (2020). Orthodox Christianity and modern human rights: Theorising their nexus and addressing Orthodox specificities. In Global Eastern Orthodoxy: Politics, religion, and human rights (pp. 13-39). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-56919-1_2
Martínez-Torrón, J. (2001). Freedom of religion in the case law of the Spanish Constitutional Court. BYU Law Review, 711.
Martínez-Torrón, J. (2006). Religious freedom and democratic change in Spain. BYU Law Review, 777.
Mattei, L. (2023). Jehovah’s Witnesses and bioethics, right to treatment and religious freedom. BioLaw Journal-Rivista di BioDiritto, 2S, 219-241. https://doi.org/10.15168/2284-4503-2847
Mayer, K. U. (2018). Whose lives? How history, societies, and institutions define and shape life courses. In Contextual influences on life span/life course (pp. 161-187). Routledge.
Murphy, C. A. (2023). A comparative analysis of the doctrine of bodily resurrection in Jehovah’s Witnesses versus traditional Christianity. https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/masters/1091/
Murtaza, M., Ali, S., Shahbaz, W., & Elger, B. (2021). Doctor-patient confidentiality: A cross-sectional study of opinions among medical students and doctors. Discover Journal of Public Future, 4, e16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43399-021-00010-8
Nampewo, Z., Mike, J. H., & Wolff, J. (2022). Respecting, protecting and fulfilling the human right to health. International Journal for Equity in Health, 21(1), 36.
Nowak, M. (2021). Introduction to the international human rights regime (Vol. 14). Brill.
Obidimma, E. O. (2019). Fundamental right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion and the right to refuse medical treatment on religious grounds under Nigerian law. African Journal of Constitutional and Administrative Law, 1. https://ezenwaohaetorc.org/journals/index.php/AJCAL/article/view/768
Olumese, O. (2021). Duty without liability: The impact of Article 12 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights on the right to health care in Nigeria. African Human Rights Law Journal, 21(2), 1112-1134. http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1996-2096/2021/v21n2a44
Organization, W. H. (2019). Global action plan on physical activity 2018-2030: More active people for a healthier world. World Health Organization.
Pejchal Grünwald, V. (2022). European Convention on Human Rights and national constitutional orders. In Encyclopedia of contemporary constitutionalism (pp. 1-18). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-56919-1_2
Petrini, C. (2014). Ethical and legal aspects of refusal of blood transfusions by Jehovah’s Witnesses, with particular reference to Italy. Blood Transfusion, 12(Suppl 1), s395. https://doi.org/10.2450/2013.0175-13
Peyton, M. A. (2020). The sanctity of blood: Jehovah’s Witnesses and bloodless medicine. Hektoen International: A Journal of Medical Humanities. https://hekint.org/2020/01/29/the-sanctity-of-blood-jehovahs-witnesses-and-bloodless-medicine/
Radovanović, M., Končar, I., Vujčić, A., & Davidović, L. (2021). The right of Jehovah’s Witnesses to refuse and to accept blood transfusion. Vojnosanitetski pregled, 78(7), 782-788.
Ramcharan, B. G. (2021). The concept and present status of the international protection of human rights: Forty years after the universal declaration (Vol. 13). BRILL.
Ramírez-Salazar, C., Jiménez-Corona, M., & Rivera-Cisneros, A. (2003). Legal aspects in cases of blood transfusion in Jehovah’s Witnesses. Gaceta Médica de México, 139(4), 423-425.
Rashid, M. H. (2024). Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on legal professionals in Bangladesh: A study findings in Dhaka City. American Journal of Society and Law, 3(1), 34-39. https://doi.org/10.54536/ajsl.v3i1.2907
Rongved, F. K. (2024). Modern medicine and obeying God: How the Watchtower Society legitimizes the controversial teaching of refusing blood transfusion. The University of Bergen. https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.22336.00004
Şaramet, O. (2020). The right to protection to health or the right to health?–Constitutional approaches. Jus et Civitas: A Journal of Social and Legal Studies, 71(1), 29-40. https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=979034
Shah, T. S., Franck, M. J., & Farr, T. F. (2012). Religious freedom: Why now?; defending an embattled human right. Witherspoon Institute.
Shanafelt, T. D., Schein, E., Minor, L. B., Trockel, M., Schein, P., & Kirch, D. (2019). Healing the professional culture of medicine. Mayo Clinic Proceedings. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0025619619303453
Shaw, R. M. (2019). Altruism, solidarity and affect in live kidney donation and breastmilk sharing. Sociology of Health & Illness, 41(3), 553-566. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9566.12805
Simović, M. N., & Simović, M. M. (2021). Protection of the right to life and Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Right to Life, 359. http://www.iksi.ac.rs/izdanja/yearbook_novi_sad_2021.pdf#page=359
Solanes Mullor, J., & Torres Pérez, A. (2019). The Constitution of Spain: The challenges for the constitutional order under European and global governance. In National Constitutions in European and Global Governance: Democracy, Rights, the Rule of Law: National Reports (pp. 543-590). https://library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12657/22841/1/1007320.pdf#page=557
Spencer, J. R. (2002). A point of contention: The scriptural basis for the Jehovah’s Witnesses’ refusal of blood transfusions. Christian Bioethics, 8(1), 63-90. https://doi.org/10.1076/chbi.8.1.63.8761
Stanislovas, T. (2019). International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
Türmen, J. Šilih v. Slovenia1 (Application No 71463/01) European Court of Human Rights (Grand Chamber). 9 April 2009.
General comment no. 14 (2000), The right to the highest attainable standard of health (Article 12 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights), (2000).
Utomo, L. Ethics and law in clinical practice: Principles of how to understand an ethical dilemma.
Vandemeulebroucke, T., Denier, Y., Mertens, E., & Gastmans, C. (2022). Which framework to use? A systematic review of ethical frameworks for the screening or evaluation of health technology innovations. Science and Engineering Ethics, 28(3), 26. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11948-022-00377-2
Varkey, B. (2021). Principles of clinical ethics and their application to practice. Medical Principles and Practice, 30(1), 17-28.
Viola, A. M. B. d. (2015). Conséquences de la classification des droits de l’homme en générations par rapport á la justiciabilité des droits sociaux. Journal of the Faculty of Law and Political Science, 4(124), 32. https://doi.org/10.18566/rfdcp.v46n124.a02
Weissbrodt, D. (2021). The right to a fair trial under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: Articles 8, 10 and 11 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Vol. 1). Brill. http://66.36.242.93/reports/ccpr_c_mli_2003_2.doc
Whitehead, A. R., & Chryssides, G. D. (2022). Contested Concepts in the Study of Religion.
Wicks, E. (2022). Article 2–Right to Life. The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights,
Yaroshenko, O. M., Steshenko, V. M., Anisimova, H. V., Yakovleva, G. O., & Nabrusko, M. S. (2021). The impact of the European court of human rights on the development of rights in health care. International Journal of Human Rights in Healthcare, 15(5), 501-513. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJHRH-01-2021-0011
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Dia A Abu Fannas Abdel Jawad
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
